A librarian swipes right on a charming high school teacher, only to realize that she’d already dated him once-and it ended in disaster. Leti Maldonado has heard all the dating horror stories, but she never expected to be part of one after coming out of a four-year dating hiatus. When she matches with Julian Gutierrez, she doesn’t think much of how familiar his profile picture looks.

But when the date goes awry, it unlocks the terrible first date memory that made her quit dating in the first place-because she’s been on this date before. And it’s just as bad the second time around. To make matters worse, at the end of the night she discovers Julian lives in the same apartment building as her and his roommate is her younger brother.

From then on, he’s inescapable. In the mailroom. In the stairwell.

Outside her door with a takeout mix-up. He’s even a witness to yet another of Leti’s terrible first dates. When Julian suggests taking over her dating accounts, he makes a surprisingly convincing case.

If Leti’s proved anything, it’s that she sure doesn’t know how to pick ’em. How much worse can Julian be at picking dates for her? It’s a terrible idea, but at this point he might be her only hope of finding real, lasting love. If they don’t fall for each other in the process, that is…